By: Christine Van Cauwenberghe, B. Comm (Hons), LL.B., TEP, CFP, RRC, Head of Financial Planning
Every estate plan is different and your plan should address your particular needs. Whether you own a business,
have a blended family or share a vacation property, your estate plan should ensure your wishes are clear, your family
is protected and your legacy will live on.
There are many elements that make up a properly structured estate plan; and many misconceptions about the
process as well. Let us clarify what you need to know to create the right plan for your loved ones
Christine Van
Cauwenberghe,
B. Comm (Hons), LL.B.,
TEP, CFP, RRC
Head of Financial Planning
This is a general source of information only. It is not intended to provide personalized tax, legal or investment advice, and is not intended as a solicitation to purchase securities. For more information on this topic or any other financial matter, please contact an IG Consultant. Trademarks, including IG Wealth Management and IG Private Wealth Management, are owned by IGM Financial Inc. and licensed to subsidiary corporations. Insurance products and services distributed through I.G. Insurance Services Inc. (in Québec, a Financial Services Firm). Insurance license sponsored by The Canada Life Assurance Company (outside of Québec).
© Investors Group Inc. 2022 EST2035MA_E (02/2023)
The short answer is “yes;” but the key is not to have just any will – you need a will that is structured to meet your needs. While standard form will kits may be valid, there are many situations where they aren’t appropriate and don’t include the types of provisions required to meet specific needs. Here are a few examples of situations where you need to have a properly drafted will.
GUARDIANSHIP
The most important time to have a will in place is when you have young children. You will need to designate a guardian in your will (along with an alternate) so that someone is prepared to take physical custody of your children and their assets if you (and the child’s other parent) die before they’ve grown up. You should speak to your proposed guardian in advance of including them in your will to ensure they are prepared to take on this obligation. If they choose not to accept the responsibility after you pass away, they could leave your children in a difficult position and potentially expose them to a custody dispute. Discussing the concept with your proposed guardian in advance is a better way to ensure your children are properly taken care of after you are gone.
PERSONAL REPRESENTATIVES
One very important function of a will is to designate the person (or persons) who will administer and distribute your estate once you pass away. This person is sometimes referred to as an executor, liquidator or estate trustee, depending on your province of residence.
For this reason, it is vital that you appoint an appropriate personal representative in your will.
Here are a few factors to consider when choosing a personal representative:
Are they capable of handling the job? Speak with your proposed personal representative before appointing them in your will to ensure that they are prepared to accept the position and are capable of carrying out their duties. If you have extensive assets or business interests, be sure to choose someone with sufficient business acumen to manage your assets after you are gone. Not everyone is suited to the role; if your proposed choice is uncertain about accepting the position, ask your IG Consultant to provide him or her with a copy of our special report, Acting as a Personal Representative.
Are they a resident of your province or territory? At a minimum, are they a resident of Canada? If your personal representative is not a resident of your province, the court in certain jurisdictions may require they post a bond before being authorized to act (which usually involves private financing), or in a worst-case scenario, the court may refuse to accept their appointment. A non-resident of Canada could also be required to file additional tax returns in the country where they reside. If you do not have any close friends or family who live in Canada, you may want to consider appointing a trust company.
GIFTS TO CHILDREN
If you will be leaving a significant amount of money to your children, then you should consider how to properly distribute those funds among them.
If your children are adults when you die and you don’t specify otherwise in your will, they will receive their full inheritances at that time, even if you feel they’re too young to receive a large sum of money. In some jurisdictions, if your child is still a minor when you die and you don’t specify otherwise in your will, then your personal representative may be required to transfer the funds to government control until your child is eligible to receive the inheritance at the age of majority (i.e. age 18 or 19 depending upon your province of residence).
In most cases, we recommend that funds for young children be left to them via a trust, and distributed in stages over a period of time (e.g. one quarter of the capital at age 25, half of the remainder at age 30, all of the remainder at age 35). Read our article, Protecting Your Child’s Inheritance, for more information on how to best leave sums of money to children.
BLENDED FAMILIES
If you are in a relationship with someone who is not the natural or adoptive parent of all of your children, then you need to balance the interests of your spouse against those of your children from any previous relationship. You probably should not sign a “standard” will that leaves everything to your spouse if he or she survives you, since there is a chance that your children will be disinherited upon the death of that spouse.
If you are in a blended family, ask your IG Consultant for a copy of our article, Estate Planning for Blended Families, which provides further detail on how to ensure a loved one isn’t inadvertently disinherited.
COMMON-LAW COUPLES (DE FACTO COUPLES IN QUEBEC)
The rules regarding the rights of common-law couples (known as de facto couples in Quebec) vary quite dramatically across Canada. Common-law couples in some provinces have many of the same rights at the time of death as a married spouse after they have lived together for the required time period (usually two or three years, again depending upon the province). In other provinces, however, they have minimal property rights, no matter how long they have lived together.
It is important to know the rules in your province and to structure your will and estate plan in a way that best reflects your intentions with respect to your partner. For more information on the rules in your province, ask your IG Consultant for a copy of our article on the rights of common-law couples in your jurisdiction.
SEPARATION/DIVORCE
If you are separated or divorced, ensure that your estate plan has been updated to meet your needs. Consider the following:
GIFTS TO GRANDCHILDREN
Some grandparents want to include gifts to their grandchildren in their wills; but are these really appropriate? Assume your will says to give $10,000 to each of your grandchildren, with the remainder of your estate to be divided equally between your children. In that case, any grandchild alive when you die will receive the $10,000 gift. But consider the following:
Unless a child has already died before you (and you are therefore unable to simply divide your estate equally between your children), your estate will be easier to administer if you avoid direct gifts to your grandchildren. Direct beneficiary designations to grandchildren on plans like your RRSP, RRIF, TFSA, pension or insurance can be particularly problematic, since in those cases it could be difficult for minor grandchildren (or their parents) to access the funds before the age of majority. Moreover, at the age of majority, the grandchildren will receive all of the assets, regardless of their ability to manage a large sum of money.
VACATION PROPERTIES
One asset that often causes family disputes is the family vacation property. Leaving a vacation property to a specific individual is not usually recommended, since it’s impossible to know how much the property will be worth when you die (or if you will even own that same property when you die).
For the most part, unless you specifically want to treat your children unequally, it is recommended that you divide your estate in equal parts (e.g. if you have two children then they would each receive half of the after-tax value of your estate; if you have three children, they would each receive one third, etc). However, what happens if one of your children is interested in receiving a particular asset from your estate (including the vacation property)? There are ways to plan for this.
Let’s assume you have three children and one of them is very attached to your vacation property, which is worth $600,000 today. First, estimate the after-tax value of your estate. Then, in order to ensure that everyone is treated equally, ensure that the entire value of your estate will be worth a minimum of $1,800,000 after tax and other liabilities (or a little more, to account for appreciation). If there is a deficiency, you may need to purchase insurance to fund the gap. This way, each child will receive an inheritance worth at least $600,000. When you pass away, your children can decide between them who would like to receive what. If the child who originally expressed an interest in the vacation property still wants it, the property can constitute their portion of your estate. Alternatively, if more than one child wants the vacation property, perhaps they will agree to each take an ownership interest as part of their interest in the estate (although joint ownership arrangements between siblings are often not practical on a longterm basis). Refer to the our article, Vacation property succession planning, for more information on the issues to consider when leaving a vacation property in your estate.
BENEFICIARIES WITH SPECIAL NEEDS
If you intend to leave some of your estate to a person who has special needs, then you should have a customized will. In many provinces, receiving a direct inheritance could disentitle a person with special needs from various social assistance benefits, such as a monthly stipend, specialized or subsidized housing, and/or medical benefits.
If a beneficiary is receiving government benefits, it is usually best to leave assets to him or her through a fully discretionary trust, sometimes referred to as a Henson trust. This is a type of trust where the trustee (as designated in your will) manages the assets for the benefit of the beneficiary, but the assets are not legally owned by the beneficiary, allowing them to continue to qualify for their benefits. Although Henson trusts may not be not fully effective in every province, there may be other reasons to use a discretionary trust, particularly if the beneficiary is mentally impaired and a trust is required to allow a third party (the trustee) to manage the inheritance.
The Income Tax Act (Canada) also allows for certain tax benefits when trusts established for individuals with special needs meet the requirements of a Qualified Disability Trust (QDT). In order to qualify as a QDT, the beneficiary of the trust must qualify for the federal disability tax credit and must be specifically named as the beneficiary of the trust in the will.
Certain other conditions must also be met in order to be considered a QDT. Speak to your IG Consultant and/or legal advisor about whether or not Henson trusts and qualified disability trusts have a place in your estate plan.
BUSINESS OWNERS
If you own a business, you need a business succession plan to preserve the value of your business for your heirs and minimize the income tax consequences of your death. Read our article, Tax and estate planning – for business owners, for more information on this topic.
CHARITABLE DONATIONS
If you want to leave some or all of your estate to charity, you need a properly drafted will. Be sure to:
Do you worry about minimizing probate fees on your estate? Many do; yet probate fees, which apply exclusively in common-law jurisdictions, are usually insignificant in value compared to the income tax liability that an estate may face. In addition, many probate planning strategies result in unintended consequences (e.g. unequal division of an estate in circumstances where assets are intended to be left equally to children).
Here is a review of how an individual is taxed at the time of death and what can be done to plan for this tax liability.
INCOME TAXES
Income taxes are often an estate’s biggest liability. Here is a summary of how these taxes are calculated:
Speak to your IG Consultant about doing an estate analysis to determine what the after-tax value of your estate may be. If the income tax payable at death will result in an after-tax value significantly lower than anticipated, you may want to consider buying permanent life insurance to fund the difference. In addition to the above, if you have U.S. connections (i.e. you own U.S. property or are a U.S. resident, citizen or Green Card holder), it is possible that U.S. estate tax may also be payable. Speak to a Canada-U.S. cross border tax expert if you believe you may have a U.S. estate tax liability.
DEFERRING OR MINIMIZING THE INCOME TAX LIABILITY
Are there any methods to defer or minimize the income tax liability at death? There are limited opportunities to shift taxable income to a beneficiary or avoid the tax altogether, but here is a summary of the most common approaches:
There are limited ways to minimize or eliminate taxes on your estate. In most cases, the recommended planning strategy is to ensure that your estate receives sufficient life insurance proceeds in order to fund this liability, so as to maximize your beneficiaries’ inheritances. Ask your IG Consultant to do an estate analysis with you to determine how much insurance you may require to meet your personal needs.
Your estate may also have to pay probate fees (also known as estate administration taxes in Ontario). Generally speaking, probate fees range from as little as $140 in the Yukon, to approximately 1.5% of the value of the estate in British Columbia, Nova Scotia and Ontario. Although the dollar amounts can become large when dealing with larger estates, probate fees are usually insignificant in comparison to income taxes. In Quebec, probate fees do not apply.
Some individuals mistakenly believe that adding a joint owner to their assets or a direct beneficiary will reduce taxes, when in fact, those strategies relate to possibly reducing probate fees, not income taxes. In addition, these strategies often result in large amounts of assets being directly transferred outside of an estate, putting the personal representative in a difficult position when attempting to distribute the remaining estate.
Let’s look at an example:
The following are some of the more popular probate planning strategies and their drawbacks:
DIRECT BENEFICIARY DESIGNATIONS
Many different types of plans and policies allow for the designation of a direct beneficiary (e.g. RRSPs, RRIFs, TFSAs, pensions, and insurance policies). In Quebec, direct beneficiary designations are generally only allowed on insurance and annuity products.
Direct beneficiary designations can help to reduce probate fees and are quite useful in the following situations:
In many cases, direct beneficiary designations are not recommended as they can result in unintended consequences. Here are a number of scenarios in which direct beneficiary designations are generally not recommended:
As you can see, there are many instances where designating a direct beneficiary is not recommended. Speak to your IG Consultant about your specific situation before making a decision. Many people mistakenly believe that so long as their will indicates a specific distribution (e.g. that all of their children will receive an equal portion of their estate), that those provisions will take precedence over everything else. It’s important to remember that, generally speaking, the terms of your will only govern the assets that form part of your estate, not those distributed outside of your estate through direct beneficiary designations. This is why direct beneficiary designations can result in disputes between beneficiaries.
JOINT OWNERSHIP WITH RIGHT OF SURVIVORSHIP (APPLICABLE EXCLUSIVELY IN COMMON-LAW JURISDICTIONS)
Another strategy commonly believed to reduce income taxes upon death is to add a joint owner to certain assets. In the common- law provinces and territories, adding a joint owner with a right of survivorship may help to reduce probate fees since the asset may pass directly to the survivor, reducing the value of the estate and the corresponding fee payable (note: right of survivorship is not recognized in Quebec). This does not, however, reduce the income tax liability.
In fact, adding a joint owner often causes confusion in situations with adult children since the child added as joint owner may feel that the jointly held asset will be theirs alone when the parent passes away, whereas the other children may believe the asset should form part of the estate and be divided along with the other estate assets in the proportions set out in the will. For this reason, this strategy is generally not recommended, unless completed with the assistance of an estate law specialist who drafts an additional document indicating what the intention is with respect to the distribution of the jointly held asset. Ask your IG Consultant for a copy of our article, Adding an adult child as joint owner to property in common-law jurisdictions, for more information on the problems that can arise when an adult child is added as a joint owner to an asset.
Even adding a spouse as a joint owner may not be recommended in all cases. As mentioned previously, if you are in a blended family, you may not want to leave all of your assets to your new spouse, as doing so could inadvertently disinherit your children from a previous relationship. If you intend to leave a part of your estate to your children, you should not hold all of your assets in joint ownership with your new spouse, as there will be no assets in your estate to distribute to your children.
JOINT OWNERSHIP: FURTHER CONSIDERATIONS
Even if you are in a first relationship, you may not want to add your spouse as a joint owner of your assets if you are concerned about how your assets may be distributed in the event of separation or divorce. In a number of provinces, assets acquired prior to your marriage or assets received as a gift or inheritance are exempt from the division of family property, but only if they are kept separate from jointly held family assets. Although the growth on assets from the date of marriage to the date of separation (or divorce) may be shareable even if they are held in your name alone, that is not the same as having to divide the entire asset. If you want to preserve at least some of the value of an asset you believe might be exempt from the division of family property, you should not be adding your spouse on as a joint owner. Note that this exception does not always apply in the case of a marital home. Speak to a family lawyer if you have an asset you would like to protect in the event of relationship breakdown.
Another problem with adding a joint owner is that, in some cases, joint owners can misuse the property for their own benefit. If your goal is to appoint someone to manage your assets in the event you become incapacitated, the solution is to appoint a trusted person as your attorney under a power of attorney document (in Quebec, mandate in case of incapacity/protection mandate) rather than giving them an ownership interest.
In some cases, more advanced probate planning strategies such as alter ego trusts and multiple wills may be recommended, particularly for high net worth individuals. If you are interested in learning more about other probate planning techniques, ask your IG Consultant for a copy of our article called “Probate fees: Four advanced financial planning strategies”.
As part of the estate planning process, you should ensure that you have documentation in place that allows someone else to manage your assets and affairs in the event you become incapacitated. These documents are often known as powers of attorney. In Quebec, make sure you establish a mandate in case of incapacity (protection mandate) in the event you become
mentally incapable. Given the nature of the position, you should choose someone with sufficient maturity who has the ability to properly manage your assets.
Also, as is the case with appointing a personal representative at the time of death, you should avoid appointing a non-resident of Canada as your attorney, as your financial advisor may be prohibited from taking instructions from that person due to securities regulations, and it may result in additional tax filings in the country where the attorney lives.
Testamentary trusts are trusts created as a result of the death of a testator, whose terms are usually included in the deceased’s will. As discussed previously, trusts are used primarily to ensure that sufficient controls are put in place in the event you die before your children reach an age when they would be mature enough to manage a large inheritance. Trusts may also be used where the beneficiary has special needs, among other situations.
A trust is a legal arrangement where a trustee (usually your personal representative) holds legal title to the trust property for the benefit of the trust beneficiaries. The trustee has the power to invest the assets and to distribute income and capital of the trust to the beneficiaries in accordance with the terms of the trust.
Where the size of the estate warrants it, you should also consider creating trusts in your will that provide not only for your children, but also their “issue,” meaning their children or grandchildren who are earning less income.
The income from the trusts could be used to pay school fees and/or the personal expenses of the various family members, but taxed in the hands of the lower income beneficiaries, resulting in less tax paid by the family as a whole. With that being said, care should be taken when including the next generation in your estate plan and we often do not recommend direct gifts to grandchildren.
Each estate plan should be customized to meet your personal needs and objectives. Generally speaking, the estate planning process involves the following steps:
IDENTIFY YOUR BENEFICIARIES
Every life situation is different and requires a customized plan. You should make a list of the people and charitable organizations you wish to benefit from your estate. For the most part, it is not recommended that a will include a long list of specific gifts – usually, the easiest method is to divide the value of your estate into portions and then allow your beneficiaries to pick and choose which assets they want to receive as part of their share. If you want to make a list of personal effects such as family heirlooms or household furnishings, consider leaving that list with your personal representative, so that he/she is aware of your wishes.
CALCULATE THE NET VALUE OF YOUR ESTATE
Ask your IG Consultant to perform an estate analysis to estimate the aftertax value of your estate. Understand, though, that assets left outside of your estate (i.e. through direct beneficiary designations or, in common-law jurisdictions, joint ownership with right of survivorship agreements) may not be available to be distributed according to your will. If you are in a situation where you have a number of beneficiaries (e.g. a new spouse plus children from a previous relationship), ensure that the value of your estate is sufficient to meet everyone’s needs, primarily those dependent upon your support.
INSURE THE GAP
If you discover that the after-tax value of your estate will not be sufficient to achieve your desired objectives, consider ways to fund the difference. For the most part, life insurance is the most effective way to do this, assuming that you are young and healthy enough to buy insurance at a reasonable rate. Do not delay in completing this part of the process, as you may reach a point in your life where this funding solution is no longer available. Once you have decided how you would like your estate to be distributed, you will also need to speak to an experienced estate lawyer or notary to help you draft a will that is appropriate for your needs. You should also consider signing a power of attorney (in Quebec, mandate in case of incapacity or protection mandate) in the event that you become incapable of managing your assets. Be sure to research the credentials of your chosen legal advisor carefully to ensure that you have an estates expert to advise you on these issues. There are many things to consider when starting the estate planning process. Your IG Consultant can help you gain peace of mind and focus on what’s best for your family and loved ones.
Christine Van
Cauwenberghe,
B. Comm (Hons), LL.B.,
TEP, CFP, RRC
Head of Financial Planning
Christine is Head of Financial Planning at IG Wealth Management, where she provides advice to high net worth clients on complex tax and estate planning issues. Christine is a member of the Canadian Tax Foundation, has her Certified Financial Planner designation and is a Registered Retirement Consultant and Trust & Estate Practitioner, certified by the Society of Trust & Estate Practitioners (STEP). She is also the recipient of the prestigious STEP Founder’s Award. Christine is the author of Wealth Planning Strategies for Canadians, which is published annually by Thomson Carswell and is currently in its 16th edition. Christine has given lectures to numerous professional associations and is a regular media spokesperson for IG Private Wealth Management.
Author
As a CERTIFIED FINANCIAL PLANNER professional since 2004 and frequent financial educator, Jeff specializes in tax-efficient portfolio management, providing sound advice and financial support to corporate or small business owners and retirees.
Written and published by IG Wealth Management as a general source of information only, believed to be accurate as of the date of publishing. Not intended as a solicitation to buy or sell specific investments, or to provide tax, legal or investment advice. Seek advice on up to date withholding rules and rates and on your specific circumstances from an IG Wealth Management Consultant. Trademarks, including IG Wealth Management and IG Private Wealth Management are owned by IGM Financial Inc. and licensed to its subsidiary corporations.